Texas appeals court upholds $100,000 fee award against an HOA after an architectural denial with no recorded basis
Originally published: September 29, 2026
Summary added November 16, 2026
Summary
On September 29, 2026, the Third Court of Appeals affirmed an order requiring the Davis Spring Property Owners' Association in Williamson County, and its board president, to pay a homeowner's attorney's fees. The owner had applied in 2020 to build a backyard accessory structure she described as a home office. The architectural review committee denied it as too tall. The trial court later declared that the 2002 design guidelines were the only guidelines on file in the county records when she applied, that they contained no height restriction that would prohibit the structure, and that the committee therefore had no authority to deny the application on that ground. It awarded $100,000 in fees under Texas Property Code §5.006 plus conditional appellate fees. On appeal, the association argued that §5.006 did not apply, but the court held it had not raised that argument in the trial court and so did not preserve it. The court also rejected the association's fee-segregation challenge. The memorandum opinion is not a ruling on the merits of the design guidelines themselves, which the association did not appeal.
Why it matters for Texas boards
Before denying an application, a Texas architectural committee should be able to point to a specific provision in a dedicatory instrument that was filed in the county real property records when the owner applied. A wrong call can cost the association the owner's legal fees, so contested denials belong in front of the association's attorney early.
Read the ruling: the memorandum opinion (PDF) in No. 03-24-00592-CV. Texas Property Code §5.006 says a court "shall allow" reasonable attorney's fees to a prevailing party who brought an action based on breach of a restrictive covenant. §202.006 says a dedicatory instrument has no effect until it is filed in the county real property records.
Press coverage: the New York Post reported on November 9 that, according to figures from the homeowner's attorney, the association owed about $153,000 in fees, costs, and interest as of November 5, and that the homeowner said the association has agreed to pay. Those figures come from one side of the case and are not in the opinion.
For your committee: our new Architectural Review Decision Checklist walks through confirming the recorded rule, writing the denial notice, and handling a §209.00505 hearing.
Related on this site: Board templates/architectural review decision checklist · Texas hoa condo law/#arc
This is an independent summary written by Texas HOA Board Resources. All reporting credit belongs to Texas Third Court of Appeals (Austin). Facts are as reported by the source on the date shown.