Houston board conduct meetings liability court decisions

Appeals court: Montgomery County POA not liable for volunteer treasurer's fight with an owner after a board meeting

Source: Texas Thirteenth Court of Appeals
Originally published: November 12, 2026
Summary added November 16, 2026
Read the original →

Summary

On November 12, 2026, the Thirteenth Court of Appeals affirmed summary judgment for the Lake Bonanza Property Owners Association in a suit from Montgomery County. An owner who had been recording a board meeting in October 2023 got into a verbal and then physical altercation with the association's elected treasurer about seven minutes after the meeting was adjourned. The owner sued the treasurer and the association, claiming the association negligently trained, supervised, or retained the treasurer and was vicariously liable for his conduct. The court held that an elected, volunteer board member was not shown to be in an employer-employee relationship with the association, and that the dispute was a personal one outside the treasurer's duties. It also noted the board president had told the treasurer not to interact with the owner. The case was transferred from the Beaumont court of appeals. The claims against the treasurer personally were severed and were not part of this appeal.

Why it matters for Texas boards

The association won, but only after nearly two years of litigation over a confrontation at its own clubhouse. Boards should adopt and enforce a simple code of conduct, end meetings on the record, and keep personal disputes with owners out of board business.

Read the ruling: the memorandum opinion (PDF) in No. 13-26-00054-CV. A memorandum opinion applies existing law to one set of facts. Another case with different facts, such as a director acting on assigned association business, could come out differently.

Practical steps for any board: state the adjournment time in the minutes, have the presiding officer handle disruptions during the meeting under written rules, and route owner complaints about a director through the full board rather than one-on-one conversations. Owners often record meetings, so plan for calm, documented proceedings.

Related on this site: Board templates/board meeting agenda · Texas hoa condo law

This is an independent summary written by Texas HOA Board Resources. All reporting credit belongs to Texas Thirteenth Court of Appeals. Facts are as reported by the source on the date shown.